County transit contract given to worst performer, appeal says

Milwaukee Transport Services, the non-profit that currently manages the Milwaukee County Transit System, has filed an appeal to the decision to award the management contract to the Dallas, TX based for-profit corporation MV Transportation. This appeal is connected to the lawsuit filed challenging the decision.

The appeal revealed that MV Transportation actually received the lowest technical score, meaning that MV got the lowest score on the portion of its bid describing how it would provide the actual bus services to riders. That section of the evaluation was supposed to count for 80% of the total score used to determine which company would be awarded the contract.

This shows a complete disregard for bus riders. Despite claims by the County that it was trying to improve the bus system by turning over operations to a private corporation, we have seen from the actions of this panel that this was not the intention.

The entire justification for awarding the bid to MV Transpotation seems to revolve around cost. MV has given a the County a low-ball offer for administrative costs.

ProviderAdministrative Price
US Average for Similar Transit SystemsAbout 18% of total budget.
Milwaukee Transport ServicesAbout 14% of total budget.
MV TransportationAbout 4% of total budget.

The County did not compare the proposals with the actual figures from similar bus systems to MCTS. A comparison shows that Milwaukee is already has one of the lowest administrative costs and that MV’s offer is probably “too good to be true”.

ProviderAdministrative Costs
Minneapolis (Metro)13.56% of total budget.
Milwaukee (MCTS)13.86% of total budget.
Pittsburgh (Port Authority)13.92% of total budget.
Kansas City (KCATA)15.89% of total budget.
Cincinnati (Metro)16.31% of total budget.
Louisville (TARC)16.38% of total budget.
St. Louis (Metro)17.06% of total budget.
Columbus (COTA)17.30% of total budget.
Cleveland (GCRTA)19.14% of total budget.
Indianapolis (IndyGo)19.36% of total budget.
Detroit (DDOT)19.71% of total budget.
Alameda (AC Transit)20.97% of total budget.
Providence (RIPTA)22.43% of total budget.
Denver (RTD)22.44% of total budget.
US Average for Similar Transit Systems17.74% of total budget.
MV Transportation4.03% of total budget.

MV Transportation did not disclose how they came up with this extremely low figure. We believe that this is cause for concern and something that should be looked into.

There is an Administrative Determination Review Committee that is looking over the decision to transfer the operations of the transit system to MV Transportation. The committee was scheduled to meet Tuesday, but that has been cancelled due to the extreme cold weather.

Waukesha cuts bus service again

In another blow to regional transportation, Waukesha has opted to reduce service on all but two Waukesha Metro routes. This sweeping reduction in service comes at the same time that there is strong support for expanding transit in the region.

The changes will take effect Thursday January 2, 2014.

  • Route 1
    – Saturday service hours shortened. (Last trip eliminated.)
    – Sunday service hours shortened. (First westbound and last eastbound trips eliminated.)
  • Route 2 will not be affected in this round of cuts. Route 2 was shortened in a separate reduction that took place in summer.
  • Route 3
    – Weekday service hours shortened. (Service will end at 7:12pm)
  • Route 3/15
    – New route will replace Saturday service on Waukesha #3 & #15.
    – Saturday service hours shortened. (Service will end at 6:47pm instead of 9:47pm on present #3.)
  • Route 4
    – Saturday service hours shortened. (Last trip eliminated.)
  • Route 5 will turn around at the Shoppes of Fox River. It will no longer run to Fox Run and Badger Drive.
  • Route 5/6
    Weekday evening service is eliminated.
    – Eliminated all service south of Sunset Drive.
    – Alternating trips will run to the Waukesha Food Pantry.
    – Saturday service hours shortened. (Last trip eliminated.)
  • Route 6 will no longer run to Waukesha West High School all day. Service will be reduced to 2 AM trips and 2 PM trips. Route 6 will travel to Badger Drive.
  • Route 7
    – Weekday evening service eliminated and replaced by Route 7/8.
    – Saturday service eliminated and replaced by Route 7/8.
  • Route 8
    – Weekday evening service eliminated and replaced by Route 7/8.
    – Saturday service eliminated and replaced by Route 7/8.
  • Route 9
    – The last northbound Weekday trip (9:12pm) has been eliminated.
    – The last northbound Saturday trip (6:50pm) has been eliminated.
  • Route 15
    – Pearl/Commerce loop eliminated.
    – Will run on Sunset between Tenny and Gramling.
    – Saturday service will be eliminated. A new Route 3/15 will replace Saturday service on Routes 3 & 15.
  • Route 16 will not be affected. (Rt. 16 runs two trips Weekdays only.)

New study looks at ways to connect Milwaukee with jobs in the suburbs

The Public Policy Forum has released a report about the lack of bus service to suburban job centers, how to fix this problem and the challenges that are holding us back.

The report focused on three potential routes that would connect Milwaukee to suburban job hubs.

  • 10X (Brookfield Square to UWM via Downtown)
  • 80X (Woodcreek/Puetz to MATC Mequon)
  • 351 (108th/Cleveland to Westridge Business Park in New Berlin)

The report also outlined many of the challenges facing transit advocates and government officials who want to connect Milwaukee with jobs. Among the largest concerns was that of funding.

We encourage anyone who wants to find out more to go ahead and read the report. It is packed with information, but is still a very easy read.

Southridge shutting out bus riders

Officials at Southridge mall have issued a demand to the Milwaukee County Transit System to stay off the mall property starting the first of November.

Bus riders will be forced to walk the length of a city block through Southridge’s parking lot to get to the nearest entrance. Buses would pick up, drop off and layover at the Southridge Park & Ride Lot, where the Route 46 Loomis-Southridge Flyer currently stops. This change will take place on Friday November 1.

The move that Southridge is forcing would put undue burdens on persons with disabilities and seniors. The move would also jeopardize the safety of all bus riders, who would have to walk across a busy parking lot to get to and from the new bus stop.

Stay tuned for action(s) to oppose this move. In the meantime, if you want to contact officials with your opinions of this move, feel free to do so. We recommend keeping your comments respectful and concise.

Milwaukee County Board

DistrictNameTransit Committee MemberPhone
17Anthony Staskunas(414) 278-4247

Milwaukee County Office for Persons w/ Disabilities
Don Natzke, Director
901 N. 9th St. Room 307-B
Milwaukee, WI 53233
http://county.milwaukee.gov/OPD

Lawsuit raises questions over transit contract bidding process

Milwaukee Transport Services, the current operator of the bus system, has filed a lawsuit in order to get more information regarding the secretive bidding process being undertaken to award a contract to manage the bus system.

MTS, the non-profit has run the bus system for 38 years and has been twice awarded for good management was passed over in favor of MV Transportation, an out-of-state for-profit company with a spotty performance record.

MTS is seeking the reasons why MV was selected and a halt on secret contract negotiations between MV Transportation and Milwaukee County.

County: For-Profit Company Selected to Take Over Bus System

Milwaukee County officials announced yesterday that MV Transportation, a Texas-based, for-profit company to manage the Milwaukee County Transit System.

This is a big change from the status-quo, currently the bus system is run by Milwaukee Transport Services, Inc., a non-profit organization created in 1975 to run the bus system.

This will take MCTS further down the road of privatization. MCTS has operated like a non-profit or government organization up until now. If the contract is approved it will go into effect January 1, 2014; at that point MCTS will start operating like a for-profit business and try to turn a profit off of our fares.

What does this mean for Milwaukee bus riders?
Privatization often means paying less for more. Milwaukee bus riders have been somewhat insulated from this by a provision in the request for proposals, but we still have several concerns:

  • Passenger amenities MCTS has, in recent years, has attempted to add amenities to the bus system and make it more enjoyable to ride. Privatization and the profit motive exerts downward pressure on the budget for amenities and capital improvements – making transit much less pleasant to ride… even making it downright unpleasant to ride.
  • Employees’ working conditions While many riders don’t realize it, the working conditions for transit employees do affect us. We benefit from having a bus system that can attract good, polite drivers and attentive maintenance workers. Profit-driven transit results in declining working conditions for transit employees, which puts us directly at risk of being involved in accidents and degrades the quality of our rides.
  • Service Cuts The concerns listed above contribute to a negative perception of public transportation and make it less attractive as a travel option to people who have other options. This will result in less people riding the bus, which will result in less revenue and more cuts to service.

As a result, we stand against this and other proposals to privatize our system.

Waukesha to trim service, add stop at Woodman’s store

The City of Waukesha, which operates the Waukesha Metro Transit system has approved changes to two of it’s routes.

Waukesha Metro operates 11 routes and sub-contracts the 900-series Wisconsin Coach routes into Downtown. Buses typically run every 60 minutes, with some a couple of routes running every 30 minutes. It is a very basic service with only one connection to the Milwaukee County Transit System: Waukesha Route 1.

The changes will be happening to Waukesha Routes 1 and 2 and will take effect on July 1st.

Waukesha Route 1
The loop on Brookfield Road and Corporate Drive will be eliminated.
Waukesha Route 1 will continue to connect with Route 10.

Waukesha Route 2
The rush-hour only section between Target/Kossow Rd and Goerkes Corners Park & Ride will be eliminated.

Waukesha Route 2 will also be slightly modified to stop at the new Woodman’s store on Main Street in Waukesha.

State Budget Update: Staying in the fund

Early on Wednesday morning, at the end of the final meeting that the Joint Finance Committee was having on the budget a large motion was passed including a provision keeping transit in the transportation fund.

While transit will be staying in the transportation fund, the 4% restoration will be shifted to 2015. This is problematic for Milwaukee bus riders, since the one time grants propping up service will expire in the beginning of 2014.

You can read the full wrap-up motion here.

Milwaukee County Board Transit Committee meets on transit projects, civil rights policies

Federally Assisted Transit Projects for Milwaukee in 2013
The Transportation, Public Works & Transit Committee of the Milwaukee County Board met today and discussed several federally assisted transit projects, including:

  • Software for an upcoming Real Time Passenger Information system that will provide real-time bus arrival times to riders.
  • An expansion of driver shields. Transit system officials have the goal of every bus having a shield by the end of 2013. The new buses coming to Milwaukee streets this year will come with shields equipped. These shields are different from the all clear plexiglas one we are used to, they will have a metal lower portion and a plexiglas upper.
  • About $15 million in bus maintenance, $12 million of which will come from the Feds.

To see a list of all the Federally-assisted transit projects for 2013, click here.

Civil Rights Policies
Also discussed by the Committee today was how the Milwaukee County Transit System will implement new civil rights policies mandated by the Federal government.

These new requirements are great for us, the riders. Among other things they push for more public involvement in decision making on routes and fares.

The Feds are requiring the bus system to create a formal Public Participation Plan. According to the informational report presented at today’s meeting, the bus system hopes to have had two meetings by fall of this year.

We will keep you posted on the dates, times and locations of these meetings as we get the information. These meetings will be a good opportunity for average bus riders to be heard. We hope that these meetings will be held at locations and times of the day that work for most bus riders, particularly people of color and people with limited English proficiency who we believe need more inclusion into the planning process.

The heat is on! Call your legislators if you haven’t already

Bus riders must not let their guard down in the wake of a partial victory. We are not out of the woods yet.

Call your legislators and let them know how important transit is to you. You can call toll free hotline at 1-800-362-9472.

The Joint Finance Committee is not the last stop in the budget process. The 4% may be changed or even lost entirely in the weeks ahead unless bus riders speak up.