State Budget Update: A Compromise in JFC

Yesterday the Joint Finance Committee took up Amendment 431 to the State Budget. This amendment, also known as the Transportation Omnibus, closed the $63 million deficit for 2015 and included some benefits to transit riders:

  • 4% of the 10% annual cut in State transit aid has been restored.
  • Transit will still be removed from the transportation fund in 2015, but only for a one year period.

What the second point means remains to be seen. Keep reaching out to your elected officials and let them know how important transit is!

Other details of the transportation omnibus:

  • Delay $14 million in spending on the Zoo Interchange until the 2015-2017 budget.
  • Delay $19 million in spending on the Ryan Road/I-94 exit until the 2015-2017 budget.
  • Cut $12 million from repairing State highways.
  • Cut $10 million from the Hoan Bridge project.
  • Cut $7.3 million in major highway development funding.
  • Cut $2.5 million from routine highway maintenance.
  • Shift $900,000 from an air quality program to one for repairing highways.

Get your written comments in for the budget – cutoff is today

Not able to make the official budget hearings, but you still want to weigh in? No problem, the Joint Finance Committee is accepting written input on the budget. Be sure to email your comments to BudgetComments@legis.wisconsin.gov.

More detailed contact information can be found here.

The cutoff for inclusion in the official record is today, April 30, 2013 at 5:00pm, so the sooner you send in your comments, the better. You can still submit budget comments after that date up to the point where the legislature is through considering the budget, however those comments will not be part of the Record of Committee Proceedings (ROCP), a report that is distributed to legislators.

Grant Resigns Effective May 1

Milwaukee County Transit System managing director Lloyd Grant is resigning. Grant will be leaving May 1, 2013.

This comes after a few questionable decisions from MCTS, such as arranging for fareboxes that don’t produce transfers, stonewalling low income and youth bus passes and overlooking an error on a bid that prompted an emergency contract for TransitPLUS service.

Grant will be succeeded by deputy manager Mike Giugno.

The Milwaukee Transit Riders Union is looking forward to new leadership of the bus system and optimistic as to what this will mean for Milwaukee bus riders.

What does the call for new transit management mean for bus riders?

Milwaukee County officials have announced today that they will seek bids for management of the transit system. (Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel story)

The Milwaukee County Transit System is partially privatized. Milwaukee County government owns the buses and buildings and sets policy like fares and routes. The actual day-to-day managing, community relations and planning is done by a private company; Milwaukee Transport Services, Inc.

Milwaukee Transport Services, Inc. (MTS) has been managing the transit system since 1975. They have their own set of positives and negatives; on the plus side they are a not-for-profit and as a result they are not profit-driven to provide the least amount of service for the highest cost. On the down side they are not as open and transparent as they should be, which presents serious questions about their accountability. They have also been very reluctant to embrace innovations that make riding the bus more pleasant and attract new riders.

We will be discussing this issue in depth as an organization to find out what can be done as part of the contract process to make bus riders’ experiences better. For instance, the county can add performance measures to the contract that mandate improvements to attract new riders and help transit dependent riders.

Analysis of the State transportation budget

Gov. Scott Walker has released his recommended budget. Unfortunately, he ignored all of the recommendations of the Transportation Finance and Policy Commission in his transportation budget.

The transportation budget

Cuts not restored
Transit aid from the state was cut 10% across the board in the previous state budget, resulting in cuts to bus service across the state. Milwaukee was able to avoid most cuts with funds that expire in early 2014. The Transportation Commission recommended reversing the cut and restoring the money taken from transit, but that recommendation has been ignored.

Transit funding will remain flat
State money to local transit systems will be frozen at 2012 levels. Since the cost of running buses increases with inflation like everything else, this is actually a service cut.

Moving transit out of the transportation fund
This is the biggest danger of the budget. If transit is moved out of the transportation fund it will be pitted against other crucial programs like education in the General (GPR) fund where it will be cut year after year. This is the same problem that Milwaukee County has, where transit service has declined 20% since 2000.

Transit IS transportation and it belongs in the transportation fund, not the overburdened general fund. Bus riders deserve the same treatment and consideration that drivers get, not a budget that marginalizes them.

No regional transportation authorities
One of the key recommendations of the Transportation Finance and Policy Commission was to create regional transportation authorities (RTAs) to fund buses and roads. These RTAs were to raise money and spend 75% of it on transit and 25% of it on roads. As with other common-sense recommendations of the Commission that would have raised the standing of bus riders in Wisconsin, this recommendation has been ignored.

An RTA would potentially have had a positive effect on the Milwaukee area, which is the most segregated major metro area in the nation according to the Census Bureau.

UPDATE $1 billion for freeway megaprojects, $0 for bus riders
Gov. Walker has announced plans to borrow $1 billion for freeway construction. This is a surprise to bus riders, who have been told that restoring $9.3 million to transit service annually is too expensive.

Summary
This budget is a step backwards for transit, economic justice, environmental justice and sustainability in Wisconsin. We need our leaders to show vision and push for a 21st century transportation network in Wisconsin.

New Meeting Times

Download flyer

Starting April 6, 2013; the Milwaukee Transit Riders Union will be having it’s monthly meetings at 10:00am.

We are making this change to ensure that we have wheelchair accessible space for our meetings.

Starting with the next meeting people should enter through the parking lot door on the south side of the building. Please do not try to enter through the front door, it will be locked. This is because we will be using the rear hall for all of our meetings.

There are no other changes to our meetings. We will continue to meet on the first Saturday of each month and meet at the Amalgamated Transit Union Local 998 Hall.

For more information, see the flyer detailing these changes, and the meetings page on our site.

#Meeting DateTimeAgenda Items Due byAt
2013-01Saturday, January 05, 20131:00pmFriday, December 28, 20125:00pm
2013-02Saturday, February 02, 20131:00pmFriday, January 25, 20135:00pm
2013-03Saturday, March 02, 20131:00pmFriday, February 22, 20135:00pm
2013-04Saturday, April 06, 201310:00amFriday, March 29, 20135:00pm
2013-05Saturday, May 04, 201310:00amFriday, April 26, 20135:00pm
2013-06Saturday, June 01, 201310:00amFriday, May 24, 20135:00pm
2013-07Saturday, July 06, 201310:00amFriday, June 28, 20135:00pm
2013-08Saturday, August 03, 201310:00amFriday, July 26, 20135:00pm
2013-09Saturday, September 07, 201310:00amFriday, August 30, 20135:00pm
2013-10Saturday, October 05, 201310:00amFriday, September 27, 20135:00pm
2013-11Saturday, November 02, 201310:00amFriday, October 25, 20135:00pm
2013-12Saturday, December 07, 201310:00amFriday, November 29, 20135:00pm

It’s Transit Week in Wisconsin

It is Wisconsin Transit Week February 4-10, 2013. There is a social media campaign on Twitter in support of strong transit using the hashtag #WITransit. When you are out and about, on the bus, or even on the computer at the library or at home after your trip please log in to Twitter and tweet to that tag about how the bus helps you.

Governor Walker has issued a proclamation observing this week. The state is watching at a crucial time – the 2013-2015 budget process is underway and we need the cuts that were made in the 2011-2013 budget to be reversed. Which they should be – Wisconsin’s 81 transit systems provide public transit access for 55% of the state’s population.

According to a statewide study 48% of transit riders use the bus to get to work and another 23% use it to get to school. Transit plays a crucial role across the state. Transit also helps the environment as well, by saving 4.2 billion gallons of gas and reducing carbon emissions by 37 million metric tons each year, reducing pollution and promoting cleaner air. Households with vehicles that are close to public transportation drive on average 4,400 fewer miles a year – using approximately 200 fewer gallons of gas and saving a lot of money.

Transit is very important to Wisconsin, so hop on Twitter and share your story today.

Analysis of the Transportation Commission Report

On January 23 the Transportation Finance & Policy Commission released it’s final recommendations. This is the commission that Governor Walker created as part of the 2011-2013 Budget.

The Commission made several recommendations that are key to strengthening bus service.

  • Restoring the 10% cut to transit aid that was part of the 2011-2013 State Budget. (Page 77)
  • Restore an additional $9.5 million to bring transit aid back to historic levels. As recently as 2002 the State contributed 50% of the Milwaukee County Transit System’s budget. (Page 77)
  • A state transit capital program of $15 million annually. (Page 79)
  • Keeping transit in the transportation fund. (Page 80)
  • Authorizing Regional Transportation Authorities (RTAs). These RTAs would have elected boards, taxing authority of up to a half-cent sales tax of which 75% would go to buses and 25% to roads. (Page 83)

What’s next?
It is now up to the State legislature and the Governor to act on these recommendations. Governor Walker will be giving his budget address in February, when he’ll release his recommended budget for the next two years. Now is the time for bus riders to be heard. You can contact the governor by email (govgeneral@wisconsin.gov) or by mail at

Office of Governor Scott Walker
115 East Capitol
Madison, WI 53702

Sample Letter

Could democracy suffer a setback in Milwaukee?

Transit riders should know about an far-reaching proposal to be announced today. A bill will be unveiled today by State Rep. Joe Sanfelippo [brother of American United (Red) Cab magnate Michael Sanfelippo] to drastically curtail the abilities of the County Board of Supervisors.

This bill would cut the budget of the Milwaukee County Board by 85%, cut the pay of supervisors to $15,000/year and reduce the board to a part-time status. This could make our mission of fighting for expanded transit much harder, since the County has the responsibility over routes, fares and the other on-the-ground details of the transit system. A part-time County Board may not have enough time to make these decisions. Getting a hold of your County Supervisor to may become hard as well.

Sanfelippo, a former County Supervisor, brought forth a similar measure at the County level in 2011 that failed to gain enough support. In a move that has been described as a slap in the face to local control and democracy, he will be introducing this bill at the State level today.

We’ll keep you posted on further developments on this bill. Details are expected to be released mid-day today.

Thanks to volunteers for talking to bus riders

We would ike to extend a sincere thank you to the volunteers that showed up to help us talk to bus riders and pass out information and comment cards about the changes. Our face-to-face efforts helped people understand the changes.

You may have seen or heard us on WUWM, TMJ4 or FOX6, or read us in the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel discussing our concerns with the GreenLine MetroEXpress, the service that replaced Route 15 on Oakland Avenue. We compared the new GreenLine schedules to the Route 15 schedules (prior to the changed routing) and found that service was scheduled to run significantly slower than the previous Route 15 service on Oakland between Wisconsin and Bayshore, despite MCTS removing roughly a dozen stops in each direction and increasing frequency. It is our position that since this service was marketed as a faster trip than the 15, it should be. The transit system countered by their Route 15 schedules were incorrect (even though they had made no prior efforts to correct them) and that the new service would be faster – while offering no proof of this.

As it stands now, a trip on the GreenLine from Wisconsin to Bayshore takes approximately 35-45 minutes. Of the three current routes that go to Bayshore from Downtown to Bayshore, the GreenLine is actually the slowest.

Bus Route Travel Time
Rt. 10 Cass/Wisconsin to Bayshore(The bus hits Cass roughly 3 minutes after it leaves Water/Wisconsin) 28-30 minutes
Rt. 15 Milwaukee/Wisconsin to Bayshore 19-32 minutes
GreenLine Water/Wisconsin to Bayshore 35-45 minutes

Eliminating stops and increasing frequency should have the opposite effect. The other two express routes, the BlueLine and RedLine, have eliminated stops and boosted frequency and as a result buses are running faster. Why can’t riders on the new GreenLine expect the same?

We think it may have something to do with the planning. Unlike the Red and Blue lines, the GreenLine was not designed to run alongside a local route. On the RedLine, for instance, it operates alongside Route 62. While Route 62 can accomodate the short-trip neighborhood riders, the RedLine can accomodate long-distance crosstown riders. The end result: buses don’t have to stop so often. This does not exist for the GreenLine – there is no local route, so all riders have to ride one bus; a bus that will make frequent stops. This is not express service.

In the coming months we will continue working hard for better transit in the region, more outreach and accountability to riders and solutions to the budget problems of MCTS. These changes were a creative use of a two-year grant. If we do not address the funding problems that MCTS has, we will be back at square one in two years’ time.